Jim Benton is associated with Nothnagle Realtors, Rochester’s leading real estate company since 1948. The firm specializes in residential sales across Monroe County, offering comprehensive buyer and seller services with award-winning agents who know local neighborhoods like Brighton, Pittsford, and Webster.
Rochester’s real estate market demands an agent who truly knows the area. Jim Benton Nothnagle Real Estate represents the expertise and local knowledge you need when buying or selling in Western New York. With decades of market experience and award-winning service, this is your complete guide to working with one of Rochester’s most established real estate teams.
Why Choose Nothnagle Real Estate
Nothnagle Realtors fields 10 times as many agents as Mitchell Pierson Jr. Inc. Realtors, the second-ranked firm on the list. This market dominance translates to unmatched resources for your real estate transaction.
The company’s foundation rests on innovation. John worked at Kodak and conceived the idea of taking photos of homes for sale and displaying them in a photo gallery for prospective buyers – so they wouldn’t have to drive out to see the homes. This forward-thinking approach continues today through advanced digital marketing and virtual tour technology.
Your transaction benefits from proven systems. The first real estate TV show in the nation – called the Nothnagle Sunday Showcase of Homes – aired on May 5, 1985. This marketing expertise helps your property reach more qualified buyers.
Agent Awards and Recognition Program
Nothnagle’s commitment to excellence shows through their comprehensive awards system. The company celebrates its agents’ achievements through various awards, including the Platinum, Gold, Silver, and Bronze Awards.
Top performers earn special recognition. Twelve agents were inducted into Nothnagle’s “Circle of Excellence” which recognizes career longevity and achievements. This includes established professionals like Roger Benton, who serves the Gates area.
Recent award winners demonstrate consistent quality. Three “Rookies” were announced: from the Buffalo-Niagara Region, the award went to Peter Goldstein (Amherst) and from Rochester the winners were Margie DiPaolo (Pittsford) and Theresa Downham (Penfield).
Award Categories Explained
| Award Level | Requirements | Recognition |
|---|---|---|
| Platinum | Highest sales volume | Top tier producers |
| Gold | Strong sales performance | Consistent achievers |
| Silver | Solid transaction record | Reliable professionals |
| Bronze | Growing sales success | Emerging talent |
Services and Market Coverage
Nothnagle provides comprehensive real estate services across Rochester’s most desirable neighborhoods. They’re the pros you want on your team when navigating the Rochester housing market. But what makes them so great, especially in the vibrant neighborhoods of Amherst and Penfield?
Specialized Services
Luxury Properties Nothnagle announced today the launch of its “Homes of Distinction” program which provides a comprehensive, global strategy to market properties listed at $750,000 or more. This program includes professional photography, targeted marketing, and international exposure.
Buyer Representation Your agent handles property searches, negotiations, and closing coordination. They provide market analysis to ensure you make competitive offers without overpaying.
Seller Services From pricing strategy to marketing execution, Nothnagle agents position your home for maximum exposure and quick sale.
Rochester Market Expertise
Local knowledge sets Nothnagle apart in Rochester’s diverse neighborhoods. These professionals are deeply familiar with Rochester’s diverse neighborhoods—from the historic homes of Brighton and the canal-side charm of Pittsford to the lakeside views of Irondequoit and the family-friendly appeal of Webster.
Current market conditions favor informed buyers and sellers. In Rochester, NY, the median home value is $170,305. However, the median listing price for Rochester homes is $226,500, and the median sale price is $177,483.
Neighborhood Specializations
Brighton and Pittsford Historic character homes with excellent school districts. These areas attract families seeking established neighborhoods with mature trees and walkable communities.
Webster and Irondequoit Lakefront properties and suburban family homes. These locations offer Lake Ontario access and recreational opportunities.
Gates and Greece Affordable starter homes and growing communities. These western suburbs provide excellent value for first-time buyers.
Customer Reviews and Experience
Nothnagle Realtors is currently rated 5 overall out of 5. This rating reflects consistent client satisfaction across different transaction types.
Client testimonials highlight key strengths. Our Realtor did the research and showed me what other houses were going for and he sold the houses within 24 hours for a good price.
Speed and pricing accuracy matter to sellers. Nothnangle Realtors helped us move and they sold the house within 24 hours. This quick turnaround demonstrates effective marketing and competitive pricing strategies.
Getting Started with Your Transaction
Contact Nothnagle through their main Rochester office. 217 W Main St · Rochester, NY 14614 · +1 (585) 461-4110 Their central location provides easy access to all Rochester neighborhoods.
Schedule your initial consultation to discuss your specific needs. Whether buying your first home or selling a luxury property, their agents tailor their approach to your situation.
Expect comprehensive market analysis, realistic timelines, and clear communication throughout your transaction. Your agent will explain each step and keep you informed of market changes that might affect your plans.
FAQ
Q: How long has Nothnagle Real Estate been serving Rochester?
A: We were founded in 1948 by the late John T. Nothnagle, a real estate innovator and pioneer. This gives them over 75 years of local market experience.
Q: What makes Nothnagle different from other Rochester real estate companies?
A: Their market dominance, innovative marketing approach, and comprehensive agent award system ensure you work with proven professionals who know Rochester neighborhoods intimately.
Q: Do they handle luxury properties?
A: Yes, their “Homes of Distinction” program provides specialized marketing for properties over $750,000, including international exposure and professional marketing materials.
Q: What areas of Rochester do they serve?
A: Nothnagle covers all Rochester neighborhoods including Brighton, Pittsford, Webster, Irondequoit, Gates, Penfield, and surrounding Monroe County communities.
